Affectivefallacy is a term from literary criticism used to refer to the supposed error of judging or evaluating a text on the basis of its emotional effects on a reader. The term was coined by William Kurtz Wimsatt, Jr. W.K. Wimsatt and Monroe Beardsley as a principle of New Criticism . The Concept The concept of affectivefallacy is an answer to the idea of impressionistic criticism, which argues that the reader s response to a poem is the ultimate indication of its value. It is the antithesis of affective criticism, which is the practice of evaluating the effect that a literary work has on its reader or audience. First defined in an article published in The Sewanee Review in 1949, the concept of an affectivefallacy was most clearly articulated in The Verbal Icon , Wimsatt s collection of essays published in 1954. Wimsatt used the term to refer to all forms of criticism that understood a text s effect upon the reader to be the primary route to analyzing the importance and success of that text. This definition of the fallacy, if strictly followed, touches on or wholly includes nearly all of the major modes of literary criticism, from Ovid s docere delictendo to teach by delighting , Aristotle s catharsis , and Longinus literature Longinus s concept of transport to late nineteenth century belles lettres and the contemporary Chicago Critics . For Wimsatt, the fallacy led to a number ... of different critics difficult, if not irrelevant. In this light, the affectivefallacy ran afoul of the New ... plane, the critical approach denoted as affectivefallacy was fundamentally unsound because ... As with many concepts of New Criticism, the concept of the affectivefallacy was both controversial ... on AffectiveFallacy The AffectiveFallacy is a confusion between the poem and its results ... Object. ELH 63 1996 227 254. Wimsatt, W.K & Monroe Beardsley, The affectivefallacy , Sewanee Review ... critics. Early commentary deplored the use of the word fallacy itself, which seemed to many critics ... more details
, a fallacy is incorrect reasoning in argument ation resulting in a misconception. By accident ..., making fallacies more difficult to diagnose. Also, the components of the fallacy may be spread ... s Organon Sophistical Refutations Sophistici elenchi . This taxonomy is as follows Accident fallacyFallacy of Accident or Sweeping Generalization Accident fallacyFallacy of Accident or Sweeping ... is ignored . Converse accident Converse Fallacy of Accident or Hasty Generalization Converse accident Converse Fallacy of Accident or Hasty Generalization argues from a special case to a general ... fallacy Also called Ignoratio Elenchi , a Ignoratio elenchi red herring Affirming the consequent ... is correct, but is insufficient proof in and of itself. Non sequitur logic Fallacy of False Cause Non sequitur logic Fallacy of False Cause or Non sequitur logic Non Sequitur incorrectly assumes .... Fallacy of many questions Fallacy of many questions or loaded question groups more than one question ... Straw man A straw man argument is an informal fallacy based on misrepresentation of an opponent s position ... s actual quote and used to discredit the argument. It is a form of False attribution attribution fallacy ... Reasoning A Practical Guide to Fallacy free Arguments publisher Cengage Learning year 2008 edition ... to modify with the adverb. Fallacy of composition Fallacy of Composition Fallacy of composition Fallacy ... that the composite item has that property. This can be acceptable i.e., not a fallacy with certain ... but lack the ability to function properly as a group. Fallacy of division Division Fallacy of division ... does not literally mean that one s domicile is in that location. Reification fallacyFallacy of misplaced concreteness Fallacy of Misplaced Concretion Reification fallacyFallacy of misplaced concreteness Fallacy of Misplaced Concretion , identified by Whitehead in his discussion of metaphysics, this refers to the reification fallacy reification of concepts which exist only in discussion ... more details
Unreferenced date December 2009 Orphan date December 2009 An affective sensation is a sensation accompanied with a strong compulsion to act on it, causing reflex action s such as the scratch reflex or the withdrawal reflex . Affective sensations are transmitted via the spinothalamic tract through the spinal cord . See also Central nervous system DEFAULTSORT Affective Sensation Category Reflexes Neuroscience stub ... more details
The notion of affective design emerged from the field of Human Computer Interaction HCI Norman, 1986 and more specifically from the developing area of affective computing Picard, 1997 . Aims Affective computing aims to deliver affective interfaces Reynolds, Picard, 2001 capable of eliciting certain Emotions emotional experiences from users McCarthy, Wright, 2004 . Similarly, affective design attempts to define the subjective emotional relationships between consumers and Product business products and to explore the affective properties that products intend to communicate through their physical attributes. It aims to deliver Virtual artifact artefacts capable of eliciting maximum physio psychological pleasure consumers may obtain through all of their senses . References Carliner, S. 2000 Physical, Cognitive, and Affective A Three Part Framework for Information Design online , available http saulcarliner.home.att.net id newmodel.htm accessed 10 January 2007 McCarthy, J. and Wright, P. 2004 . What is enjoyment doing to HCI? In ECCE 12 Proceedings of the 11th European Conference on Cognitive. European Association of Cognitive Ergonomics, Le Chesney, France. pp. 11 12 Norman, D. A. 1986 . Design principles for human computer interfaces. In D. E. Berger, K. Pezdek, & W. P. Banks Eds. . Applications of cognitive psychology Problem solving, education, and computing. Hillsdale, NJ Lawrence Erlbaum Associates. Reynolds, C. and Picard, R. 2001 Designing for Affective Interactions. In Proceedings of 9th International Conference on Human Computer Interaction, August 5 10, 2001, New Orleans, Louisiana, USA. online , available http vismod.media.mit.edu pub tech reports TR 541.pdf Category Design Category Marketing comp sci stub ... more details
Affective memory , also known as emotional memory, is an element of Stanislavski s system Stanislavski s system and of Method Acting , two related approaches to acting. Affective memory requires actors to call on personal memories of situations similar or more recently a situation with similar emotional import to those of their characters. Stanislavski believed actors needed to take emotion and personality to the stage and call upon it when playing their character. He also explored the use of objectives, the physical body s effect on emotions, and empathizing with the character. Emotional recall is the basis for Lee Strasberg s Method Acting . Sense memory is used to refer to the recall of physical sensations surrounding emotional events instead of the emotions themselves . The use of affective memory remains a controversial topic in acting theory. See also Presentational acting and Representational acting Emotion and memory Stanislavski system External links http www.theatrgroup.com Method sense memory.html Method Acting sense memory Category Acting techniques ... more details
Affective science is the scientific study of emotion or Affect psychology affect . This includes the study of emotion elicitation, emotional experience and the recognition of emotions in others. In particular the nature of feeling, Mood psychology mood , emotionally driven behaviour, decision making, attention and self regulation, as well as the underlying physiology and neuroscience of the emotions. Discussion An increasing interest in emotion can be seen in the behavioral, biological and social ... affective determinants i.e. motives, attitudes, moods, and emotions . ref http www.affective sciences.org affective sciences The National Centre of Competence in Research NCCR for the Affective Sciences See also Swiss Center for Affective Sciences Seidner identified a negative affect arousal mechanism ... vantage points, the emerging field of affective science seeks to bring together the disciplines which study the biological, psychological, and social dimensions of affect. In particular affective science includes psychology , affective neuroscience neuroscience , sociology , psychiatry , anthropology ... research focusing on the same phenomenon, emotion and similar affective processes, starting ... challenges of affective science is to reach consensus on the definition of emotions. Discussion ... basic and complex emotions. ref http www.affective science.org research.shtml Interdisciplinary Affective ... secretion. This hybrid approach should allow researchers to gradually pinpoint the affective phenomenon. Affective display Main Affect display A common way to measure the emotions of others is via ... descriptive of emotions. In both respects one may observe the way that affective display differs from culture to culture. See also Portal Psychology Music Therapy Psychology Affective computing ... Oxford University Press Series in Affective Science Dana Sugu & Amita Chaterjee Flashback Reshuffling ... sites.google.com site sugudana articles 1 DEFAULTSORT Affective Science Category Interdisciplinary ... more details
Affective Labor is a Terminology term identifying Labour economics work carried out that is intended ... its history is as old as that of Labour economics labor itself, affective labor has been of increasing .... The most visible institutionalized form of affective labor is perhaps advertising , which typically ... other areas in which affective labor figures prominently, including service industry service and care ... , frequently ignored by other analysts of labor, has also been a critical focus of theories of Affective .... Brooklyn, NY Autonomedia. ref History The phrase Affective Labor, seen broadly, has its roots in the Autonomist ... and Negri on affective labor Antonio Negri and Michael Hardt have begun to develop this concept in their books ..., Hardt and Negri focus on the role affective labor plays in the current mode of production which can .... Affective labor, then, is labor that produces or manipulates affects.... One can recognize affective ... with a smile . One indication of the rising importance of affective labor, at least in the dominant ... is another way of saying a worker is adept at affective labor ref Hardt, M. and Negri, A. 2004 Multitude ... point in their scholarship with respect to this issue is that immaterial labor, of which affective ... Betancourt has suggested that affective labor may have a role in the development and maintenance of what he has termed agnotology agnotologic capitalism . His point is that affective labor is a symptom ... blockquote The affective labor created to address this alienation is part of the mechanisms where the agnotological ... Published 6 10 2010, Arthur and Marilouise Kroker, Editors ref blockquote His construction of affective ... the reduction alienation of alienation is a precondition for the elimination of dissent. Affective labor is part of a larger activity where the population is distracted by affective pursuits and fantasies ... date September 2007 http makeworlds.org node 60 An Essay by Michael Hardt on Affective Labor http www.vinculo a.net english site text curatorial.html Affective Link. Policies of affectivity, aesthetics ... more details
Cleanup date May 2008 Affective Computing is also the title of a textbook on the subject by Rosalind Picard . Affective computing is the study and development of systems and devices that can recognize ... Tao coauthors Tieniu Tan title Affective Computing A Review booktitle Affective Computing and Intelligent ... http affect.media.mit.edu pdfs 95.picard.pdf Affective Computing MIT Technical Report 321 http vismod.media.mit.edu pub tech reports TR 321 ABSTRACT.html Abstract , 1995 ref on affective computing. ref ... to computer science was done by Pickard sic who created the field of affective computing. archiveurl ... Wired quote Rosalind Picard, a genial MIT professor, is the field s godmother her 1997 book, Affective ... for those emotions. Areas of affective computing Detecting and recognizing emotional information Detecting ... L pez, Inmaculada Fajardo year 2006 month April title Assistive Technology and Affective Mediation ... Review of Models, Methods, and Their Applications. journal IEEE Transactions on Affective ... 01 tta201001toc.htm format PDF accessdate 2010 10 15 ref Emotion in machines Another area within affective ... systems Citation needed date May 2008 . In this view, affective emotional states correspond to time ... of affective computing Emotional speech Emotional speech processing recognizes the user s emotional ... affective states via facial and vocal expressions recognition, International Conference on Multimodal ... applications In e learning applications, affective computing can be used to adjust the presentation ..., i.e. counseling , benefit from affective computing applications when determining a client s emotional state. Citation needed date May 2008 Affective computing sends a message via color or sound to express ... affective information exhibit higher flexibility while one works in uncertain or complex environments. Companion devices, such as digital pet s, use affective computing abilities to enhance ... to be angry. Citation needed date May 2008 Affective computing has potential applications in human ... more details
Merge Monitor hypothesis Acquisition learning hypothesis target Comprehensible input discuss Talk Comprehensible input Merger proposal date March 2011 Refimprove date May 2010 The affective filter is an impediment to learning or acquisition caused by negative emotion al affective responses to one s environment. It is a hypothesis of second language acquisition theory, and a field of interest in educational psychology . Major components of the hypothesis According to the affective filter hypothesis, certain emotions, such as anxiety, self doubt, and mere boredom interfere with the process of acquiring a second language. They function as a filter between the speaker and the listener that reduces the amount of language input the listener is able to understand. These negative emotions prevent efficient processing of the language input. ref Krashen, S. 2003 . Explorations in Language Acquisition and Use . Portsmouth Heinemann. ref The hypothesis further states that the blockage can be reduced by sparking interest, providing low anxiety environments and bolstering the learner s self esteem. History Since Stephen Krashen first proposed this hypothesis in the 1970s, a considerable amount of research has been done to test its claims. While the weight of that research is still not definitive, the hypothesis has gained increasing support. References Reflist Further empirical study reading Lin, G.H.C. & Ho, M.M.S. 2009 . An exploration into foreign language writing anxiety from Taiwanese university students perspectives. 2009 NCUE Fourth Annual Conference on Language Teaching, Literature, Linguistics, Translation, and Interpretation. National Changhua University of Education, Department of English, Taiwan, ROC, P. 307 318 http www.eric.ed.gov PDFS ED506178.pdf Lin, G.H.C. 2008 . Pedagogies proving Krashen s theory of affective filter, Hwa Kang Journal of English Language & Literature, Vol, 14, 113 131 ERIC Collection as ED503681 http www.eric.ed.gov PDFS ED503681.pdf SLA topics ... more details
Affective haptics is the emerging area of research which focuses on the study and design of devices and systems ... Affective Haptics publisher in Proc. 3rd Int. Conf. on Intelligent Technologies for Interactive Entertainment ...&hl en&authkey CK2M34QD format PDF doi 10.1007 978 3 642 02315 6 27 ref ref name Affective Haptics ... Kawakami, Susumu Tachi title Affective Haptics in Emotional Communication publisher in Proc. Int. Conf. on Affective Computing and Intelligent Interaction ACII 09 , Amsterdam, the Netherlands, IEEE Press ...&hl en&authkey CNivkvwP format PDF doi 10.1109 ACII.2009.5349516 ref on Affective ... wearing affective haptic devices.jpg thumb Affective haptic devices worn on a human body According ... 0033 295X.96.3.395 ref . Sense of Touch in Affective Haptics Human emotions can be easily evoked by different cues, and the sense of touch is one of the most emotionally charged channels. Affective ... Science publisher McGraw Hill year 2000 isbn 0 8385 7701 6 ref . Technologies of Affective Haptics ... experience. The heart imitator HaptiHeart ref name Affective Haptics produces special heartbeat .... HaptiButterfly ref name Affective Haptics reproduces butterflies in your stomach the fluttery ... s abdomen. HaptiShiver ref name Affective Haptics sends shivers up and down your spine through a row of vibration motors. HaptiTemper ref name Affective Haptics sends chills up and down your ... Explicit Emotion Elicitation HaptiTickler ref name Affective Haptics directly evokes joy by tickling ... Affective emotional haptic design. Recent findings show that attractive things make people feel ... 05135 9 ref . The concept of emotional haptic design was proposed ref name Affective Haptics . The core ... of wearing the device. Affective computing Affective computing can be used to measure and to recognize emotional information in systems and devises employing affective haptics. Emotional information ... signals, affective and collaborative games, psychological testing, assistive technology and augmentative ... more details
Refimprove date May 2009 The affective spectrum is a grouping of related psychiatry psychiatric and medicine medical disorders which may accompany bipolar disorder bipolar , unipolar depression unipolar , and schizoaffective disorder s at statistically higher rates than would normally be expected. These disorders are identified by a common positive response to the same types of pharmacologic treatments. They also aggregate strongly in families and may therefore share common heritable underlying physiologic anomalies. Affective spectrum disorders include Attention deficit hyperactivity disorder ref name pmid11859906 cite journal author Hudson JI, Pope HG Jr. title Affective spectrum disorder does antidepressant response identify a family of disorders with a common pathophysiology? journal Am J Psychiatry volume 147 issue 5 pages 552 64 year 1990 pmid 11859906 doi ref ref name pmid12578434 cite journal author Hudson JI, Mangweth B, Pope HG Jr, De Col C, Hausmann A, Gutweniger S, Laird NM, Biebl W, Tsuang MT title Family study of affective spectrum disorder journal Arch Gen Psychiatry volume 60 issue 2 pages 170 7 year 1990 pmid 12578434 doi 10.1001 archpsyc.60.2.170 ref Bipolar disorder Body dysmorphic disorder Bulimia nervosa ref name pmid11859906 ref name pmid12578434 and other eating disorder s Cataplexy ref name pmid11859906 ref name pmid12578434 Dysthymia ref name pmid12578434 Fibromyalgia ref name pmid12578434 General anxiety disorder ref name pmid12578434 Hypersexuality Irritable Bowel Syndrome ref name pmid11859906 ref name pmid12578434 Impulse control disorder not elsewhere classified Impulse control disorders Kleptomania Migraine ref name pmid11859906 ref name pmid12578434 Clinical depression Major Depressive Disorder ref name pmid11859906 ref name pmid12578434 Narcolepsy ... phobia ref name pmid12578434 The following may also be part of the spectrum accompanying affective ... See also Affect psychology Affect Emotion List of emotions Mood disorder Mood affective disorders Psychopathology ... more details
Psychology sidebar Affective neuroscience is the study of the neural mechanisms of emotion . This interdisciplinary field combines neuroscience with the psychology psychological study of personality psychology personality , emotion , and Mood psychology mood . Brain areas related to emotion Emotions are thought to be related to activity in brain areas that direct our attention, motivate our behavior, and determine the significance of what is going on around us. Pioneering work by Paul Broca Broca ... toward specific goals ref Davidson, R.J., & Sutton, S.K. 1995 . Affective neuroscience The emergence ... affective syndrome has been described ref Parvizi, Anderson, Damasio & Damasio, 2001 . Pathological ... emotional and emotional processes emerged as two separate fields cognitive neuroscience and affective ... ref Davidson, R.J. 2000 . Cognitive neuroscience needs affective neuroscience and vice versa . Brain & Cognition, 42, 89 92. ref . Thus, when cognition is taken at its broadest definition, affective neuroscience could also be called the cognitive neuroscience of emotion. Affective Neuroscience and Learning There are many ways affect plays a role during learning. Recently, affective neuroscience ... Bender, B Blumberg, C Breazeal, D Cavallo, T Machover, M Resnick, D Roy & C Strohecker 2004 . Affective ..., P. M. 2007 . Embodying emotion. Science, 316, 1002 1005 ref . See also Affect psychology Affective science Affective spectrum Music Therapy Psychophysiology Psychology Psychiatry References reflist ... and affective style. Trends in Cognitive Science, 3, 11 21. Freitas Magalhaes, A. 2009 . Emotional ... Panksepp, J. 1992 . A critical role for affective neuroscience in resolving what is basic about basic ... University Press. Panksepp J. 1998 . Affective Neuroscience The Foundations of Human and Animal Emotions Series in Affective Science . Oxford University Press, New York, New York. Brain and Cognition, Vol. 52, No. 1, pp. 1 133 June, 2003 . Special Issue on Affective Neuroscience. DEFAULTSORT Affective ... more details
Affective forecasting is the forecasting of one s affect psychology affect emotion al state in the future. This kind of prediction is affected by various kinds of cognitive bias es, or systematic errors of thought. Daniel Gilbert psychologist Daniel Gilbert of the department of social psychology at Harvard University and other researchers in the field, such as Timothy Wilson of the University of Virginia and George Loewenstein of Carnegie Mellon University , have studied these cognitive biases and given them names such as empathy gap and impact bias . Examples of the impact bias include over estimating emotional reactions to Valentine s Day, football games, elections, movie clips ref name hoerger and the reactions of jury juries to crime criminal trial law trial s. ref cite journal author Blumenthal, J.A. title Law and the Emotions The problems of affective forecasting journal Indiana Law Journal year 2005 volume 80 pages 155 250 ref Reasons for the impact bias include a focalism and b immune neglect. In terms of focalism, people focus too much on the target event, ignoring peripheral activities that may later occupy their attention and impact their emotional state. In terms of immune neglect, when forecasting emotions, people tend to neglect the role their coping resources will later play in ameliorating distressing affects. As such, those with effective coping strategies are actually more prone to biased affective forecasts. ref name hoerger cite journal author Hoerger, M. et al. title Immune Neglect in Affective Forecasting journal Journal of Research in Personality year ... bias in affective forecasting volume 75 journal Journal of Personality and Social Psychology year ... 2002 title Decisions and Revisions The Affective Forecasting of Changeable Outcomes journal Journal ... reason why people are poor at affective forecasting they typically underestimate the extent to which .... Zanna publisher Academic Press date 2003 volume 35 pages 380 chapter Affective Forecasting isbn 978 ... more details
Syllogistic fallacies are logical fallacy logical fallacies that occur in syllogism s. They include Any syllogism type other than polysyllogism and disjunctive fallacy of four terms Occurring in categorical syllogism s related to affirmative or negative premises affirmative conclusion from a negative premise fallacy of exclusive premises negative conclusion from affirmative premises existential fallacyfallacy of the undistributed middle illicit major illicit minor fallacy of necessity Occurring in disjunctive syllogism s affirming a disjunct Occurring in statistical syllogism s dicto simpliciter fallacies accident fallacy accident converse accident External links http www.fallacyfiles.org syllfall.html Fallacy files Syllogistic fallacy Formal Fallacy logic stub Category Formal fallacies Category Syllogistic fallacies fa he ... more details
Unreferenced stub auto yes date December 2009 A fallacy of distribution is a logical fallacy occurring when an argument assumes there is no difference between a term in the distributive referring to every member of a class and collective referring to the class itself as a whole sense. There are two variations of this fallacyFallacy of composition assumes what is true of the parts is true of the whole. This fallacy is also known as arguing from the specific to the general Since Judy is so diligent in the workplace, this entire company must have an amazing work ethic. Fallacy of division assumes what is true of the whole is true of its parts or some subset of parts . Because this company is so corrupt, so must every employee within it be corrupt. While fallacious, arguments that make these assumptions may be persuasive because of the representativeness heuristic . See also Existential fallacyFallacy of the undistributed middle Ontogeny recapitulates phylogeny Informal Fallacy DEFAULTSORT Fallacy Of Distribution Category Logic Category Logical fallacies Logic stub he ... more details
Unreferenced date December 2009 The relativist fallacy , also known as the subjectivist fallacy , is a fallacy committed, roughly speaking, when one person claims that something may be true for one person but not true for someone else. The fallacy is supposed to rest on the law of non contradiction . The fallacy, it is said, applies only to objective facts, or what are alleged to be objective facts, rather than to facts about personal tastes or subjective experiences, and only to facts regarded in the same sense and at the same time. On this formulation, the very name relativist fallacy Begging ... it clear wherein, exactly, the fallacy lies. There are at least two ways to interpret the relativist fallacy either as identical to relativism generally , or as the ad hoc adoption of a relativist stance ... fallacy which make the fallacy out to be identical to relativism e.g., Sapir Whorf hypothesis linguistic relativism or cultural relativism are themselves committing a commonly identified fallacy of informal logic, namely, Logical fallacy Begging the question begging the question against an earnest, intelligent, logically competent relativist. It is itself a fallacy to describe a controversial view as a fallacy &mdash not, at least, without arguing that it is a fallacy. In any event, it will not do ... fallacy. If one commits a fallacy, one says something false or not worth serious consideration ... be said to have committed a fallacy. The accusation of having committed a fallacy might rest on either ... that it straightforwardly contradicts the Law of Non Contradiction or 2 the defense and thus the fallacy ... interpretation of the fallacy, in determining whether the relativist fallacy has been committed, one ... facts, and so he does not commit the fallacy. References Law, Stephen 2005 Thinking Tools The Relativist Fallacy, Think Philosophy for everyone A journal of the the Royal Institute of Philosophy 3 57 58 y See also Formal fallacy Informal fallacy DEFAULTSORT Relativist Fallacy Category Logical ... more details
The psychologist s fallacy is a fallacy that occurs when an observer presupposes the objectivity of his own perspective when analyzing a behavioral event. The fallacy was named by William James in the 19th century. It is a specific form of the similar to me stereotype what is unknown about another person is assumed, for simplicity, using things the observer knows about himself. Such a bias leads the observer to presuppose knowledge or skills, or lack of such, possessed by another person. For example, I or everyone I know or most people I know don t know very much about chemistry. Therefore I can assume that this other person knows very little about chemistry . This assumption may be true in any number of specific cases, making inductive reasoning based on this assumption cogent , but is not applicable in the general case there are many people who are very knowledgeable in the field of chemistry , and therefore deductive reasoning based on this assumption may be invalid. The great snare of the psychologist is the confusion of his own standpoint with that of the mental fact about which he is making his report. I shall hereafter call this the psychologist s fallacy par excellence. William James, Principles of Psychology volume I. chapter vii. p. 196, 1890 Psychologist s fallacy, the fallacy, to which the psychologist is peculiarly liable, of reading into the mind he is examining what is true of his own especially of reading into lower minds what is true of higher. James Mark Baldwin , Dictionary of Philosophy and Psychology volume II. p. 382 2, 1902 A danger to be avoided known as the psychologist s fallacy . This arises from the fact that the experimenter is apt to suppose that the subject will respond to a stimulus or an order in the same way as he himself would respond in the circumstances. British Journal of Psychology . XXI. p. 243, 1931 The psychologist s fallacy is considered analogous to David Hackett Fischer s historian s fallacy . DEFAULTSORT Psychologist s Fallacy ... more details
Refimprove date May 2010 Wiktionary fallacy A deductive fallacy is defined as a deductive argument that is invalid. The argument itself could have true premise s, but still have a false logical consequence conclusion . ref cite web url http www.nizkor.org features fallacies title Description of Fallacies last Labossiere first Michael year 1995 publisher The Nizkor Project accessdate 2008 09 09 ref Thus, a deductive fallacy is a fallacy where deduction goes wrong, and is no longer a logical process. Logical fallacy The standard Aristotelian logical fallacies are Fallacy of four terms Quaternio terminorum Fallacy of the undistributed middle Fallacy of illicit process of the illicit major major or the illicit minor term and Affirmative conclusion from a negative premise . Other logical fallacies include The begging the question self reliant fallacy In philosophy , the term logical fallacy properly refers to a formal fallacy a flaw in the structure of a deductive reasoning deductive logical ... informal fallacy informal fallacies as well as formal fallacies valid but soundness unsound claims or poor non deductive argumentation. The presence of a formal fallacy in a deductive argument does not imply anything about the argument s premises or its conclusion see fallacyfallacy . Both may ... described. By extension, an argument can contain a formal fallacy even if the argument ... or causality can be said to commit a formal fallacy. Example File Logical fallacy.svg thumb 250px A Venn diagram illustrating a fallacy br Statement 1 Most of the green is touching the red. br Statement 2 Most of the red is touching the blue. br Logical fallacy Since most of the green is touching ..., is a false statement. In the strictest sense, a logical fallacy is the incorrect application of a valid ... fallacy is formed by points that may individually appear logical, but when placed together ... relevance fallacies formal fallacy informal fallacy DEFAULTSORT Deductive Fallacy Category Deduction ... more details
One source date September 2010 The animistic fallacy is the logical fallacy of arguing that an event or situation necessarily arose because someone intentionally acted to cause it. ref name Sowell cite book title Knowledge and decisions authorlink Thomas Sowell last Sowell first Thomas edition 3rd publisher Basic Books year 1996 isbn 9780465037384 pages 97 100 url http books.google.com books?id 4kqTMrEKWXoC&pg PA97 ref While it could be that someone set out to effect a specific goal, the fallacy appears in an argument that states this must be the case. ref name Sowell The name of the fallacy comes from the animism animistic belief that changes in the physical world are the work of conscious spirits. Citation needed date September 2010 Examples Thomas Sowell in his book Knowledge and Decisions presents several arguments as examples of the animistic fallacy ref name Sowell in the teleological argument argument from design for the existence of God that the order and complexity observed in nature must be the result of a creator that people earn wealth always because of superior choices that central planning is necessary to prevent chaos in society Sowell repeatedly dismisses the necessity that order comes from design, and notes that fallacious animistic arguments tend to provide explanations that require comparatively little time to implement. In this light he contrasts the Genesis creation narrative six day creation of the world described in the Bible to the development of life over billions of years described by evolution . See also Argument from ignorance Pathetic fallacy Reification fallacy References Reflist Informal fallacy DEFAULTSORT Animistic Fallacy Category Causal fallacies philosophy stub he ... more details
distinguish Historian s fallacy The Historical fallacy , also called the psychological fallacy , is a logical fallacy originally described by philosopher John Dewey in 1896. The historical fallacy occurs when a set of considerations which hold good only because a completed process is read into the content of the process which conditions this completed result. ref The Reflex Arc Concept in Psychology , John Dewey, 1896 ref More simply stated, one commits the historical fallacy when one reads into a process the results that occur because of that process. Example A person coming across a loaf of bread without knowing the process by which bread is made, might begin to try to understand how to make bread by analyzing only its ingredients. Finding that bread contains a large amount of air, one might conclude that air is an ingredient used in making bread. However, a baker does not add air into bread. Rather yeast creates a chemical process that causes the bread to rise with air. The fallacy is in not recognizing that air is a result of the process of making bread and not part of the process that makes it. Completed results supervene upon processes that are not necessarily reducible to the parts of that process. Applications The historical fallacy has implication in analytic philosophy and metalogic . For instance many analytic philosophers apply logic to metaphysics metaphysical questions without inquiring into the metaphysical processes underlying logic. Thus many process theorists might contend that much of analytic philosophy is undermined by the historical fallacy. See also Process theory References references External links http psychclassics.yorku.ca Dewey reflex.htm The Reflex Arc Concept in Psychology 1896 Category Logical fallacies ... more details
For other uses of prescience, see precognition . The fallacy of prescience is a term used by Smith, DeShaye and Stoicheff Who date January 2009 to describe an erroneous exploratory research technique in which the experimental scaffolding embeds assumptions about what will be discovered. The example cited describes a common practice in Humanities Computing in which an XML database and schema are designed at the outset of a research project to annotate a document as a means of discovering the structural relationships within the subject text. The fallacy, they say, arises from the fact that some inferences must be made about the structures that will be discovered in order to construct the schema that will describe them. The fallacy of prescience can be viewed as a procedural manifestation of the informal fallacy of begging the question . External links http llc.oxfordjournals.org cgi content full 21 2 199 Callimachus Avoiding the Pitfalls of XML for Collaborative Text Analysis Category Causal fallacies Category Pseudoscience ... more details
The Descriptive Fallacy was suggested by J.L. Austin in 1955 in the lectures now known as How to Do Things With Words . It is applied to reasoning which treats a speech act as if it were a logical proposition . logic stub Category Logical fallacies ... more details
The definist fallacy can refer to three logical fallacy logical fallacies related to how terms are defined in an argument. The first, coined by William Frankena in 1939, involves the definition of one property in terms of another. The second fallacy refers to the insisted use of a persuasive definition ref name IEP Fallacies cite encyclopedia title Fallacies encyclopedia Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy accessdate March 31, 2011 last Dowden first Bradley date December 31, 2010 url http www.iep.utm.edu fallacy Persuasive 20Definition ref in an argument. Finally, it can also refer to the Socratic fallacy in which terms are required to be defined before use. ref name Blackwell cite encyclopedia last Bunnin first Nicholas coauthors Jiyuan Yu encyclopedia The Blackwell Dictionary of Western Philosophy title Definist fallacy url year 2004 publisher Wiley Blackwell isbn 9781405106795 page 165 url http books.google.com books?id OskKWI1YA7AC&pg PA165 ref This article focuses on the first of these fallacies. The philosopher William Frankena first used the term definist fallacy in a paper published in the British analytic philosophy journal Mind journal Mind in 1939. ref name Frankena 1939 cite journal title The Naturalistic Fallacy first W. K. last Frankena work Mind volume 48 number 192 ... he generalized and critiqued G. E. Moore s naturalistic fallacy , which argued that good cannot ... Preston first Aaron date December 30, 2005 ref Frankena argued that the naturalistic fallacy is a complete misnomer because it is neither limited to naturalistic properties nor necessarily a fallacy ...?id lxnsElfqa70C&pg PA94 year 1989 ref On the second word fallacy , Frankena rejected the idea that it represented an error in reasoning &ndash a fallacy as it is usually recognized &ndash rather than ... two things that may be identical in fact are. ref name Flew cite encyclopedia title Definist fallacy ... the fallacy of begging the question . ref name Ridge References Reflist Category Logical fallacies ... more details
A fallacy of division occurs when one reasons logic ally that something true of a thing must also be true of all or some of its parts. An example A Boeing 747 can fly unaided across the ocean. A Boeing 747 has jet engines. Therefore, one of its jet engines can fly unaided across the ocean. The converse of this fallacy is called fallacy of composition , which arises when one fallaciously attributes a property of some part of a thing to the thing as a whole. Both fallacies were addressed by Aristotle in Sophistical Refutations . Another example Functioning brains think. Functioning brains are nothing but the neurons that they are composed of. If functioning brains think, then the individual neurons in them think. Individual neurons do not think. Functioning brains do not think. From 3 & 4 Functioning brains think and functioning brains do not think. From 1 & 5 Since the premises Entailment entail a contradiction 6 , at least one of the premises must be false. We may diagnose the problem as located in premise 3, which quite plausibly commits the fallacy of division. An application Famously and controversially, in the philosophy of the Greek Anaxagoras at least as it is discussed by the Roman Atomist Lucretius , it was assumed that the atoms constituting a substance must themselves have the salient observed properties of that substance so atoms of water would be wet, atoms of iron would be hard, atoms of wool would be soft, etc. This doctrine is called homeomeria , and it plainly depends on the fallacy of division. If a system as a whole has some property that none of its constituents has or perhaps, it has it but not as a result of some constituent having that property , this is sometimes called an Emergence emergent property of the system. External links http www.fallacyfiles.org division.html Logical Fallacy Division The Fallacy Files Informal Fallacy Category Verbal fallacies Division philo stub es Falacia de divisi n he ro Diviziunea ilogic fi V r divisio ... more details
The furtive fallacy is an informal fallacy of emphasis. Historian David Hackett Fischer identified it as the belief that significant facts of history are necessarily sinister, and that history itself is a story of causes mostly insidious and results mostly invidious. It is more than a conspiracy theory in that it does not merely consider the possibility of hidden motives and deeds, but insists on them. In its extreme form, the fallacy represents general paranoia . ref name fischer cite book first David Hackett last Fischer year 1970 title Historians Fallacies ref Fischer identifies several examples of the fallacy, particularly the works of Charles Beard . In each case, the example provides detailed portrayals of historical figures involved in off record meetings and exhibiting low morals, based on little or no evidence. He notes that the furtive fallacy does not necessarily imply deliberate falsification of history it can follow from a sincere but misguided belief that nothing happens by accident or mistake. ref name fischer Richard Hofstadter discussed the fallacy before Fischer, although not by name. In reviewing histories from the Progressive Era , Hofstadter noted the assumption that reality was always hidden and ignored, being determined by bribes, rebates, and secret business deals. ref name fischer ref name hofstadter cite book first Richard last Hofstadter year 1955 title The Age of Reform ref A modification of the furtive fallacy holds that when the historical record provides no evidence explaining a particular set of events, this is itself evidence of a furtive cause. ref name davidson cite book first Ronald M. last Davidson year 2002 title Indian Esoteric Buddhism ref Notes Reflist Further reading cite book first Joseph last Roisman year 2003 title Brill s Companion to Alexander the Great Informal fallacy Category Informal fallacies ... more details
Encyclopedia
top
